Reviews and Cat Litter Ratings
A cat litter rating changes depending on the source. We've done some research to determine which are the highest rated litter brands. After reviewing our ratings please provide us with your experiences by filling out the form below.
Cat litter is usually made from one of 7 materials (clay, sand/silica crystals, wheat, corn, pine, baking soda and newspaper). Additives are sometimes included in the mixture such as perfumes to mask odor or carbon to absorb odor..
We prefer litter that is unscented since cats are sensitive to smell. The highest rated litter is "Dr Elsey's" since it is low in dust, clumps well for scooping and is unscented. The only downside is that like all clay litter it is not biodegradable or flushable. Good alternatives are The "Worlds Best Litter" and "Swheat Scoop" which are biodegradable and flushable.
Each litter type has pros and cons. If you do not scoop daily and odor is a big problem, you may choose a scented litter or one of the other choices such as Arm and Hammer, Fresh Steps and Tidy Cat.
Fill in the comment form below to help other owners choose the best litter. We will incorporate your comments into the cat litter rating.
Table Main Title
Cat Litter Rating
Dr. Elsey's Precious Cat Ultra (our favorite clay litter)
|Clay||For cat owners who want a medium grain clay in a clumping,
low tracking litter. It features a larger, denser particle that stays
in the litter box and that keeps moisture from reaching the bottom. It
clumps very hard and will not break apart. Unscented.
99.9% Dust Free. Hypo-allergenic, contains no plant proteins. All Natural. Good for sifting/mechanical litter boxes.
Note that this brand of clay cat litter may be the best litter for your cat, but it is NOT biodegradable or flushable. It needs to be thrown out in the trash. If it was biodegradable we would rate this litter an A.
Made from all-natural, whole kernel corn traps and absorbs urine and ammonia for exceptional odor control. Flushable and septic safe. Biodegradable. Superior clumping. Easy scooping. Long lasting. Low tracking, silica dust free. Ideal for self-cleaning litter boxes.Unscented, Safe for cats and kittens. Silica dust free. Clumping action rated 8 out of 10 by Charlotte Magazine.
|Swheat Scoop Natural Wheat Litter (our highest cat litter rating)||Wheat||
Safe, fast clumping litter is made from naturally processed wheat. Biodegradable, certified flushable, safe for kittens, safe for declaws, safely digested, and guaranteed ammonia odor free. Low track formula is virtually dust free.
Best clumping all natural litter according to "Charlotte
Magazine" rated 9 out of 10.
|Feline Fresh Clumping Natural Pine Cat Litter||Pine||
Flushable, scoopable, naturally sterile and biodegradable, this Feline Fresh litter is made from 100% pure Southern Yellow Pine, which completely eliminates litter box odor.
Clumping action rate 5 out of 10 stars by Charlotte Magazine
resulting in our B+ rating.
|Arm & Hammer High Performance Clumping Cat Litter||Baking Soda||Arm & Hammer High Performance Clumping Cat Litter is a
natural alternative to clay-based cat litter.
Is a 100% Scoopable Litter With Virtually No Dust. Delivers Complete Odor Control With ARM & HAMMER Baking Soda to Destroy Odors on Contact. Biodegradable. Not flushable. Not recommended since product is scented.
|Cat's Pride Natural Scoop||Clay||
Features a natural botanical ingredient derived from fruit and vegetable extracts, delivering safe odor control.
Hypoallergenic, Low-Dust Formula
|Natures Miracle Crystals||Crystals||
These crystals made from sand absorb moisture in seconds, leaving the surface dry to the touch and trapping odor inside to keep the box fresher. Simply remove solid waste every day to keep the box clean. Crystals often last longer than traditional clay or clumping litters and may reduce the frequency of littler box changes.
|Fresh Step||Clay and/or Crystals||This product uses carbon to absorb odor. We would recommend trying the scoopable version.||Not Rated|
|Jonny Cat Natural||Clay||Features a natural botanical ingredient derived from fruit
and vegetable extracts for odor control. Allergen free, no perfumes or
dyes. Low levels of dust.
Good clumping action.
|Scoop Away Free||Clay||Tight clumping action and maximum odor control without any perfumes or dyes.. 99.9% Dust Free||Not Rated|
|Tidy Cats||Clay or Crystals||Tidy Cats Scoop® is the only brand to offer Tidy Lockâ„¢ Technology. Moist litter locks together and hardens over time, forming crumble-free clumps that make everyday scooping easy. Virtually dust-free litter granulescontrol odor.||Not Rated|
Yesterday's NewsÂ® Original Formula Cat Litter is a solution
for those who seek a cleaner, non-toxic alternative to clay cat box
fillers. Yesterday's NewsÂ® brand litters use a special process that
utilizes recycled newspaper to create distinctive pellets. The litters
are virtually dust-free, with no small particles to track around the
It is unscented, more moisture absorbent than clay, non-toxic and designed for low tracking.
While there is no official cat litter rating agency, the best advice is that provided by cat owners like yourself. Please help others by filling out this form with your experience. We will adjust each cat litter rating based on the feedback we receive.
Love it or Hate it. Share Your Experience with Different Cat Litter Brands.
Do you have some experience with cat litter brands that will help other cat owners?
What Other Visitors Have Said about Cat Litter
Click below to see contributions from other visitors to this page...
Amazing Cat Litter
Simply put, Amazing Cat Litter lasts longer, and improves odor control. It is less messy both for our cat and our floor. I almost tried corn based litter …
In my opinion Companion Essentials is the best clumping clay cat litter. Pretty low dust, very nice price. I've tried all types and can sympathize with …
Feline Pine Cat LItter User Reviews
I like just about everything about this litter. It does all that it claims to do but it tracks everywhere! I have 2 long haired cats and it sticks to their …
Priority Brand by Safeway Stores
This is by far the best clumping litter I've ever used. I normally change clumping litter every 2 weeks, but I can go for a month or more with Priority. …
User Reviews of Scoop Away Cat Litter
I have had at least three cats for almost 13 years now, & tried many brands until I settled on Scoop Away because of its value of price and low dust …
Fresh Step, Tidy Cat Not rated yet
Fresh Step is extremely dusty, and is also strongly scented. I would not recommend it for any house with an asthmatic cat or human. Tidy cats pours …
Cat's Pride Is Not Low Dust Not rated yet
Cat's Pride Low dust? I don't think so. My cat's litter box is in my personal bathroom in my bedroom, and my roommate can smell the dust all the way …
Review of Dr. Elsey's Ultra Precious Cat Litter Not rated yet
I was using the feline pine pellets, taking out the solids and putting the rest in the green waste (sawdust remains) for recycling. However, a few weeks …
Arm and Hammer Cat Litter Reviews Not rated yet
I have 2 cats who use the same extra large litter box which is scooped twice daily. As with so many products, the new, "improved" version of Arm & Hammer …
Catit Daily Scoops Litter Problem Not rated yet
We have been using Catit Daily Scoops from Rolf C Hagen for around 3 weeks now and our cat is choking and now has gone off her food. Shes is tending …
Worlds Best Cat Litter User Reviews Not rated yet
Loved it! I used World's Best Cat Litter for about a year and though it was the most expensive litter I ever used it was the favorite. Scooping and …
Jonny Cat Not rated yet
I hate Jonny Cat. It is full of dust and too much clump and stick to the pan. It makes me sick every time I enter the cat area to clean.
Swheat Scoop Cat Litter Not rated yet
Been using Swheat Scoop Cat Litter for couple of years. Love that it's natural and doesn't choke me, or my cats, with the perfume smells. I didn't …
Wood pellets for pellet-burning stoves Not rated yet
Wood Pellets are basically the same thing as Feline Pine but made from other kinds of wood (fir, frequently). At an average of $4.50 for a 40-pound …